Like you say, No engine will last forever, but this is based on the fact I have one of 5, a 55 year old M tractor handed down since I was a kid. It's never been apart, and before it dies, I will more than likely die before it does. That's forever enough. People always make this mistake. Recommended oil is the least protection granted by a new engine specs. Until one understands how oil pressure is derived, you no longer can go strictly by what it said a few years ago. Your going strictly on theory alone with that thinking. The engine now has different wear on all the critical bearings, and most people have never taken an engine apart to see the results close up. You can't even remove the pistons of an older engine with out cutting away the ridge line below the top ring where it stopped at the top of it's bore. The bore is so tapered, that the travel down is making the rings on the piston wear out the lands they sit on. All engines get this way. But it can be minimized using the correct oil for it's condition Oil pressure occurs for one reason. What the pump can deliver, and the resistance at each close tolerance bearing. As the bearings wear, this clearance is now larger, and now less resistance and now less oil pressure. Right? You can readily see this with older vehicles with oil pressure gauges and now warmed up fully, and now at idle see the pressure almost 0. This is the results of worn bearings and pump. Nothing else to look at. But one can increase this resistance simply by upgrading the oil a step at a time. There are modifiers one can purchase. I've tried them myself, and they do work. At $18 quart, it proved it worked. But it's also temporary. This is a case where someone may have to save what's left of the engine to make it through the month safely in dangerous weather. Not all farmers have money to burn 30,000 for another machine. We do what it takes to make them last beyond the norm with carefully taken steps. One can not discount perfection if it always works to ones advantage. Try building an engine to compete in drag racing. If you slack anywhere in process, you loose period. I did this for years pro- stock all over the US. Now lets clear up another misconception. 1. Flushing out old oil does not involve moving parts. All moving parts are out of view of the drain back ports in the block that go straight back into the pan. It was designed this way on purpose. You can view this flow with the pan off. This Flushing process is not for those that have normal maintenance steps in place. Although they can be modified to their advantage. This is for those who may have just purchased a machine in badly needed care. And need to process it just once in the most cost effective manner. 2. Pre filling oil filters. For one, it's recommend by JCB. I just read the manual. Once you have the filter pre filled, you simply pour off the less than 1/4 cup of oil if it's a side mounted application. Now consider some applications I service that have 3, 2 quart oil filters. Go ahead and fire this one up without pre filling them first. More like a $20,000 mistake if done. The old filter you took off spilled some as well didn't it. So make it spill into a controlled manner. One can, if fussy about it, use duct tape to tin foil to control the spill. Usually the best way to solve this is to punch a hole to drain the old filter to a controlled capture. It's not rocket science. But why have a belly full of crap in the machine. Or have to some how clean up the mess with little access to the lower area in a cat. You might want to work in there for other service. 3. Heres the problem with letting the oil filter do your job instead. On refill and run. One, the oil has to go where first to get to the oil filter? So why would you want the old trash to go into the oil pump and grind it up first on the way to the oil filter. The oil pump is the heart of your machine, no different than the one you carry around all day. As for Aircraft: Were not talking about aircraft engines at the 2200 hr mark for rebuild. You missed the point. I've had these engines apart on a regular basis at 100 hr marks. It's also the law. The most common thing done is the owners change the oil cold. The engine sat for up to a month and the dipstick comes out fairly clean. Now remove the oil pan, and see cheese an inch deep from a year ago. This is why the rules are what they are. People don't know what there doing, so they make rules to protect some. All oils break down in performance, not just from contaminates. The modifiers get used up. Engines with increased clearances will require greater flow to maintain the same pressure. Upgrading the oil can make up this difference. The oil at the bearing has to have adequate pressure to keep the shock wave of the rod bearing from making contact to the crank. It's a sledge hammer blow every power stroke. It's the same difference if wearing a tennis shoe or bare foot. Little oil pressure is like bare foot on sharp rocks vs high pressure and thick rubber soles. It keeps your foot from making contact. What one decides as a care standard will make one last over the other. It's that simple. Same as humans. Here's one more clue to flushing anytime. If you just changed the oil, and it doesn't look clean ten miles later. Then thats your style. The steps are not over kill, to get the engine to ones higher standards. In fact, they can take less time it takes you now. A micrometer will prove it in the end. Phil, Mpls Mn where we have to get stuff done at 30 below and no whining.
|